What's new
Peugeot RCZ Forum

Register a free account today to become a member. It's free! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, connect with other members through your own private inbox and take part in competitions!

Opinions please.

A

Anonymous

Guest
Should resitting your driving test in the UK BECOME COMPULSORY, or for that matter in any country.

Some coffin dodging/illegal lane changing old person ........has caused Nearly £2,000 worth damage to my new car.

1. l think it should be compulsory.
2. l know of 2 elderly people who should'nt be driving anymore "my father" just stopped recently "Avrils father.... still causing frequent road rage :crazy: :thumbdown:
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
Whaaaaaaat?!?! What happened?! That's horrifying news!! :thumbdown:

However, in response to your question, yes. I firmly believe that a re test should be mandatory at a certain point. After all, reactions are significantly slowed by the aging process. I reckon that a re test should be taken at around 70 years old and then every 5 years or so after that. Maybe that's controversial but I think it could be supported by evidence if I went looking for it.
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
jassyo06 said:
Should resitting your driving test in the UK BECOME COMPULSORY, or for that matter in any country.

Some coffin dodging/illegal lane changing old person ........has caused Nearly £2,000 worth damage to my new car.

1. l think it should be compulsory.
2. l know of 2 elderly people who should'nt be driving anymore "my father" just stopped recently "Avrils father.... still causing frequent road rage :crazy: :thumbdown:

wow ..sorry to hear that jassy ..as i allways say old people have never been involved in any accidents but theyve seen plenty in there rear view mirror :wtf: its a hard one to call some people are fine , others well :shock: how did it happen , are there any people who saw it , what damage have they caused .. hope you get sorted quick and that the car aint off the road too long
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
Gutted for you! Yes totally, totally agree on retesting. Always thought so.

Sent from my GT-N7000 using Tapatalk 4 Beta
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
jassyo06 said:
Should resitting your driving test in the UK BECOME COMPULSORY...

No!

jassyo06 said:
... or for that matter in any country.

THAT!

I'm preaching this for years. Old people really LOVE to reverse out of their garage into my doors :cry:
 

RCZ1

Active Member
Joined
Jun 5, 2010
Messages
9,562
Reaction score
23
Points
38
Location
East Riding of Yorkshire
Sorry to hear that Jassy. I hope it's soon sorted out for you.

Yes I agree, people should be retested but I think from an even younger age than 70. It should be an on going process from when you first pass your test through to the day you stop driving. Like Mr Rizz says, every 5 years at least for retesting.
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
Am over the car being damaged, the old chap swapped lanes instantly on a large stay iim lane roundabout causing damage to the front drivers side wing,alloy,door mirror obliterated,

Yes l know its a hard call ,but elderly people cause so many road incidents/accidents, they are a danger to themselves and to other road users
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
And they get cheaper insurance too. I've only had 1 car damaged in an accident and i just never felt the same about it after it was fixed gutted for u pal.
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
Gutted for you Jassy.

On the retest thing, I agree with RCZ1 we should all be re tested on a regular basis. As for 70 year olds my Mum is 70 drives a Pug 508 and is one of the best drivers I know, Dad is 72 and I fear for my life every time I get in the car.
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
My old man is over 71 and is one of the best drivers I have ever known. His ability to reverse park is mesmerising. However, my mum is in her 60s and is a woeful driver...always has been. Bad drivers will always somehow have their day and slip through the net so perhaps a more regular testing should be carried out as RCZ1 suggests. However, not necessarily as extensive a one. However, there are people still on the roads who have a licence but have never had to take a driving test as we know it. My point is that at 70 a full and comprehensive test should be undertaken then and every 5 years subsequently.
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
A retest after every motoring offence wouldn't be a bad idea too. I know it's not strictly relevant to Jassy's thinking, but if we're happy to retest people just on the basis of age without knowing if they're actually good drivers then surely testing people who've demonstrated a failing is a no-brainer.

Sent from my GT-N7000 using Tapatalk 4 Beta
 

Tomas_90

Member
Joined
Nov 11, 2012
Messages
966
Reaction score
4
Points
18
Location
Finland
stevebasshead said:
A retest after every motoring offence wouldn't be a bad idea too. I know it's not strictly relevant to Jassy's thinking, but if we're happy to retest people just on the basis of age without knowing if they're actually good drivers then surely testing people who've demonstrated a failing is a no-brainer.
Well that wouldn't really work. Having to do a full retest just because you did 65 mph in a 60 zone, or just forgot your seatbelt.

People would be upset.
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
All I would say is that we are all getting older and would you feel the same way when you have to find the funds for a retest out of your meagre pension, with the potential to loose your independence at risk. It is so easy to say what others should be made to do. I feel for jassy as I know what an absolute bummer it must be for him, however I'm not one in favour of knee jerk reactions :thumbdown: It is all too easy to say what others should have to do. One day soon it could be you they are saying to "get rid of your car now and catch the bus" and I believe that you might not all be quite so keen on this idea then.
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
jassyo06 said:
Yes l know its a hard call, but elderly people cause so many road incidents / accidents, they are a danger to themselves and to other road users

:clap:

As commented in a previous thread, once you are handed a Bus Pass, you should be mandated to hand over your Driving Licence. For every 1 passable Driver, there's 1,000's that are pants.

You've had your turn Grandads - let the Younger Generation (should be only allowed to drive once turned 25) burn you up and show you some real driving :auto-car:
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
Gorwell said:
jassyo06 said:
Yes l know its a hard call, but elderly people cause so many road incidents / accidents, they are a danger to themselves and to other road users

:clap:

As commented in a previous thread, once you are handed a Bus Pass, you should be mandated to hand over your Driving Licence. For every 1 passable Driver, there's 1,000's that are pants.

You've had your turn Grandads - let the Younger Generation (should be only allowed to drive once turned 25) burn you up and show you some real driving :auto-car:
And the youngsters are amongst the worst as they believe themselves to be invincible :roll:
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
Sorry to hear about the car m8, bad news :thumbdown:

As for compulsory testing for the elderly, then yes I would agree, but at what age do you say someone needs re-testing. :eusa-think:
For example, take your own recent accident , this old fella swapped lanes without any notice on a round about, well I've seen 21 year olds do the same thing or even worse.

Maybe there should be a system where everyone is re- tested, say, every 10 years up to a certain age , and then maybe every 5 years after this age.

Another thing that I think should be compulsory for all drivers is a system where we have to prove to the DVLA that we have passed an eye test every 3 years, to show we are suitable for driving, no matter what age the driver.

I know that we have to make a declaration about informing the DVLA of changes with these types of things, but wouldn't it be better and safer if we all had to supply written proof of eye sight / health, every couple of years or so.
The DVLA insist on an health certificate, the MOT, for a car that's over 3 years old, but not for the person driving it, total madness in my opinion.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but surely when a car or cars are involved in an accident there must be a human involved somewhere . :eusa-whistle:

I think lorry drivers and bus drivers have to supply eye test and health screening results every few years, so why not car drivers. :eusa-think:

There's a fella (ex driving instructor) living in my street who is 83 years old, had major heart surgery, a couple of strokes and wheres glass's like milk bottles, but still gets behind the wheel, "on quiet days, or at night, when no body's around", his words not mine. :?

If you took one look at him you would think he should not be allowed his zimmer frame, let alone drive a car, it's shocking. :eek:

However, there will always be the flip side to this ageism argument, you can easily find far younger drivers, in prime health and eyes as sharp as lasers, racing in and out of traffic like a Tasmanian Devil, with not a care in the world, very little driving experience and as much common sense as a cabbage.

Anyway, Jass hope you get the car sorted soon. :thumbup:
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
Tomas_90 said:
stevebasshead said:
A retest after every motoring offence wouldn't be a bad idea too. I know it's not strictly relevant to Jassy's thinking, but if we're happy to retest people just on the basis of age without knowing if they're actually good drivers then surely testing people who've demonstrated a failing is a no-brainer.
Well that wouldn't really work. Having to do a full retest just because you did 65 mph in a 60 zone, or just forgot your seatbelt.

People would be upset.
People would be upset, yes, and perhaps because of that it would be a better deterrent than fines and points alone :)

Sent from my GT-N7000 using Tapatalk 4 Beta
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
OO58RON said:
All I would say is that we are all getting older and would you feel the same way when you have to find the funds for a retest out of your meagre pension, with the potential to loose your independence at risk. It is so easy to say what others should be made to do. I feel for jassy as I know what an absolute bummer it must be for him, however I'm not one in favour of knee jerk reactions :thumbdown: It is all too easy to say what others should have to do. One day soon it could be you they are saying to "get rid of your car now and catch the bus" and I believe that you might not all be quite so keen on this idea.

I'll be honest, I'm in NO way supporting ageism here. I fully respect and give credence to what you say but if you are scrimping to get by on the meagre state pension (something that's unlikely to exist when my generation exists even after working until later in life) then surely a car is a luxury? :eusa-think: This is, in part, why pensioners are entitled to free bus travel anywhere in Scotland.

No, I wouldn't relish having to rely on bus travel but if I was reliant solely on a state pension then i don't think running a car would be a priority for me.
 
Top